Claim Contacts:

In the event of a claim, during business hours, please call our office at (716) 631-0190 and we will walk you through the process. 

After business hours, feel free to call the carrier directly. We will follow up with you when we receive notice of your claim.

        Commercial Specific
A Central                               (800) 234-6926  
Adirondack     (877) 629-8003  
Amtrust     (212) 220-7120
Chautauqua      (800) 896-4720  
Cincinnati      (877) 242-2544  
Community Mutual     (877) 302-0203 
Dryden      (800) 556-5802             
Erie     (800) 367-3743   (877) 771-3744
Erie & Niagara      (716) 983-1739   (713) 632-5433 #1, #7          
Foremost     (800) 527-3907  
Genesee Patrons     (585)343-7307 x 104- Jeff  After Hours     (800) 343-6496
Hanover     (800) 628-0250  *Platinum Auto/Home  (800)799-6977    
Harleysville     (800)892-8877
Hartford     (800) 553-1710
Liberty Mutual       (800) 362-0000
Merchants     (888) 644-6680  
National General         (800) 325-1088  
National Grange/ Main Street America          (877) 425-2467  
New York Central Mutual     (800) 234-6926  
 Progressive     (800) 274-4499  
 Safeco     (800) 332-3226  
 Tower        (888)856-5522
 Travelers     (800) 252-4633   (888) 238-6225
 United Frontier     (800) 352-0908
 Utica First        (800) 456-4556
 Utica National     (800)216-1420  
 Zurich       (800) 987-3373